Too Essential to Fail: Why Our Big Bet on Public Education Needs a Bold National Response

BY Karen Pittman and Merita Irby

From all angles of society, the appetite for systems change in public education is undeniably strong. Young people, parents, K–12 educators, business leaders, and community advocates crave a different path for education—one that aligns more directly with the interests, needs, and aspirations of our youth; one that empowers learners to contribute their gifts to their worlds; and one that integrates the vibrant wisdom and assets of our communities into the learning journeys of our young people.

To understand these dimensions more deeply, we invited Karen Pittman and Merita Irby of Knowledge to Power Catalysts (KP Catalysts) to unpack the evidence of this growing demand, and to amass existing, foundational Positive Youth Development research that undergirds the power and possibility of a community-based, learner-centered path forward.

Too Essential to Fail brings forth several dimensions of evidence, including:

  • Data that illuminates the dynamics of existing demand from the perspectives of young people, parents, educators, community, and business leaders;
  • Academic research and frameworks that showcase the positive impacts of community-based approaches; and
  • A look at organizations and networks already working at the nexus of community and education.

As we forge ahead with our collective efforts to accelerate the R&D for public education systems transformation and pilot the development of learner-centered ecosystems, this paper has fortified our teams with deeper insight into the need for, and potential of, this work.

Download the report here.

Karen Pittman headshot

Karen Pittman

Founding Partner, Knowledge to Power Catalysts

In 2021, Karen Pittman left her position as CEO of the Forum for Youth Investment to become a founding partner with Knowledge to Power Catalysts. She focuses on amplifying ideas about how, where, when, why, and with whom learning and development happens and the importance of creating equitable, learner-centered ecosystems. In addition to her work with Education Reimagined, Karen is also an AIR Scholar at the American Institutes of Research and a Governing Partner of the SoLD Alliance.

Merita irby Headshot

Merita Irby

Partner, Knowledge to Power Catalysts

As a partner in KP Catalysts, Merita works with leaders in school districts, governmental departments, community collaboratives, and non-governmental organizations nationwide. Merita’s portfolio of projects focuses on helping leaders tackle real-world complexities by developing lenses and decision-making frameworks for the whole child and whole community that are youth-centered, science-informed, and equity-focused.